Hey there,
I've been procrastinating on this newsletter for weeks. Not because I ran out of ideas or didn't enjoy writing. No -- it was more because my perceived speed of life had accelerated like an illegally tuned drag race car. On Thursday nights, I would sit at my desk and think, "Eh, I'll write it next Thursday" -- but before I knew it, the next Thursday would roll around, and the next, and the next.
But, at last, here I am, breaking the cycle by writing this on a Friday. Ha, take that, past self!
Before unpacking today's idea, I have two exciting announcements:
If you're a long-time follower of my writings, you might know I'm prone to slipping into existential crises. Sometimes, they have a specific cause. For instance, when I overly draw meaning from one thing (a relationship, work project, or hobby), and then, suddenly, that thing ceases to exist. But other times, it comes out of nowhere -- while loading the dishwasher, watching the sunset, sitting on the train.
In any case, all those funky questions erupt in my mind like a long overdue volcano. What's it all about? What am I doing with my life? And anyway, won't we all be dead in the long run? What's the purpose of anything?
Historically, religion has answered these questions (and, of course, it still does for some people). But today, in our increasingly secularized culture, many people (myself included) just rock-n-roll through life, trying to sidestep these questions as if they were dog poop. Sure, capitalism tries to give us answers by baiting us with money, fame, and status. But we know very well that these are short fixes, shallow answers.
And still.
We desperately need to answer questions on meaning and purpose -- that is, if we want life to be meaningful, full of meaning. Knowing our meaning -- our why -- simply makes life suck less. As the Holocaust survivor Victor Frankl puts it aptly: “In some ways, suffering ceases to be suffering at the moment it finds a meaning, such as the meaning of a sacrifice.”
So, how do we cope with a meaning crisis in an endlessly bureaucratized and estranged world? How can we figure out the immensely tricky question about the meaning of life when we're left on our own? I've repeatedly stumbled upon a rather unusual answer:
We should give up.
I don't mean this as giving up on playing the game of life altogether. But more as giving up on analyzing strategies and, instead, starting to play.
One of the most seminal advocates of this take is the existentialist philosopher Albert Camus. In his piece The Myth of Sisyphus, Camus discusses, well, Sisyphus -- the guy from Greek mythology who was condemned to rolling a rock uphill for eternity. How does Sisyphus, the man sentenced to the most meaningless task imaginable, find meaning?
Camus writes:
The way I interpret Camus is that the question of the meaning of life is pointless because the point is to live the question. The point is to accept that life is absurd and immerse ourselves in whatever it has to offer. Whatever is in front of us. Even if it's a rock.
Camus ends the essay with arguably one of the most famous lines of modern philosophy:
Why should Sisyphus be happy?
I think he's happy precisely because he keeps pushing his rock. "His rock is his thing," as Camus puts it. Sisyphus knows every grain of his rock, all the dull dents and sharp edges. We can imagine he's committed to figuring out the best way to push his rock up the hill, watch it roll down again, and walk back to the bottom. Sisyphus is happy because he isn't as much concerned with the meaning of life as the inevitable task in front of him.
In this sense, reflection is simply the wrong tool to answer the meaning of life. A more appropriate tool is immersion.
Matt Haig writes about the same idea in his Comfort Book (except he's packaging it far more pithy than I could):
Or imagine you're standing at the edge of a wonderfully blue mountain lake. You're thinking, "I wonder how cold the water is. What it would feel like to jump in. Would it be freezing? Would I be able to jump in? Is the ground muddy?"
These considerations would be the equivalent of Sisyphus brooding on the purpose of his rock. Once again, reflection is the wrong tool. The only way to find out what mountain lakes feel like is to submerge ourselves in them. How long do we need to keep brooding on the meaning of life until we allow ourselves to live?
But my favorite take on this topic, by far, comes from Hermann Hesse's Siddhartha:
While reading all this, you probably didn't wonder why I used X word or Y punctuation (provided I didn't produce word salad). No, instead, you're letting yourself -- in this very moment! -- carry by the words. You're flowing in a river of letters, words, sentences, paragraphs. And you effortlessly absorb their meaning.
Searching for the meaning of life in an absurd world demands us to do the same. We must stop deciphering every last venture and start absorbing what's right here, right now.
It's counterintuitive but perhaps not surprising that we don't make life more meaningful by endlessly wondering how we might find purpose. We make life more meaningful by immersing ourselves in it. By rolling the rock. By eating the toast.
By living.
Until next time,
Stephan
Thanks for reading! To respond, just hit reply. I love getting questions, feedback, and comments, and they're (by far) my biggest motivators to keep writing this newsletter. If you know someone who'd enjoy this email, simply forward it (or share this link: [ARCHIVE URL GOES HERE]).
I'm an engineer turned writer turned philosophy student. Join my weekly-ish treasure hunt for ideas that make life a little less sucky. No soulless blah. No advice to get up at 5 am. Just some succinct (and often unconventional) thoughts. New posts every Thursday - if my writer's block allows it.
Hello! Before we dive in, some organizational stuff... First, I've seen a rich influx of new subscribers recently – thanks for being here! This newsletter is about becoming an Amateur. This typically includes ideas on half-assing more things, adopting a more effortless mindset, and embracing imperfections (as I'm trying to recover from my own perfectionistic tendencies). Also, it's where I give the occasional update on my writer's life. Of course, all this happens on a highly irregular...
Last week, I was sitting in the dimly lit bar of a hostel in Amsterdam, where I nursed a tulip-shaped glass of IPA, feeling thrilled to write. It was a child-like thrill, the type that rushes through your body right before ripping open a giant birthday present. And so, like unwrapping a present, I opened up my laptop, created a new document, and found... ...nothing. Suddenly, I stared at an aggressively blinking cursor on a blank laptop screen. It occurred to me that, surely, no one would...
Hi, my name is Stephan, and I’m an amateur. No, I’m not having yet another existential quarter-life crisis. I’m actually doing better than ever, creatively speaking. And here’s why. For well over three years (!), this newsletter was called Thoughtful Thursday. There are several reasons I baptized my literary baby like this. First, I wanted the name to sound smart (duh). Second, I wanted it to be an alliteration (ostensibly, a modern writer’s favorite stylistic device). But, of course, these...